2027 alertSecurity Health Plan, UnitedHealthcare, Aspirus Health Plan and 2 other companies end some Medicare Advantage plans in Wisconsin on December 31. (CMS data) 15 days left in Annual Enrollment (ends Dec. 7).Is your plan ending? →
Compare

SeniorCare vs. Medicare Part D

SeniorCare is Wisconsin's prescription drug assistance program for residents 65 and older. Wisconsin DHS says it counts as creditable coverage, as good as standard Medicare Part D, so you won't owe a Part D late penalty while you keep it. You can have SeniorCare alone, Part D alone, or both; with both, Part D pays first and SeniorCare pays last.

What you are comparing

SeniorCare is a state program run by the Wisconsin Department of Health Services (DHS) under Wis. Stat. 49.688. It helps Wisconsin residents 65 and older who are U.S. citizens or qualifying immigrants pay for prescription drugs and vaccines. It's based on income only; you pay a yearly enrollment fee per person, and what you pay at the pharmacy depends on your income level. Levels 1 and 2A run under a federal waiver approved through December 31, 2028. See SeniorCare in Wisconsin.

Medicare Part D is Medicare's drug coverage, sold by private plans, either as a standalone drug plan or inside a Medicare Advantage plan. CMS lists 8 standalone Part D plans in Wisconsin for 2027. In 2027, your out-of-pocket cost for covered drugs is capped at $2,400, and covered insulin costs no more than $35 a month. See Part D in Wisconsin.

Side by side

QuestionSeniorCareMedicare Part D
Who can get itWisconsin residents 65 and older (citizens or qualifying immigrants), not in full-benefit MedicaidAnyone with Part A or Part B who lives in the plan's service area
What it costs to joinA yearly enrollment fee per person; no monthly premiumA monthly premium set by the plan (higher-income people also pay an IRMAA amount)
What you pay at the pharmacyDepends on your income level: copays, a deductible, or a spenddown firstSet by the plan, up to the $2,400 yearly cap in 2027
Which drugsMost brand and generic drugs; Levels 2B and 3 cover only drugs whose makers signed a state rebate agreement. Recommended vaccines at a pharmacyThe drugs on the plan's formulary
Where it worksPharmacies that take Wisconsin Medicaid, which DHS says is more than 95% of Wisconsin pharmaciesThe plan's network pharmacies, which can include pharmacies outside Wisconsin
When you can joinAny time once you're 65; renew every yearYour Initial Enrollment Period, October 15 to December 7, or a special enrollment period
Late penalty?Counts as creditable coverage: no Part D penalty while you have itA penalty can apply if you go 63 days or more without creditable coverage
Works with Extra Help?DHS says people eligible for Extra Help must pick a primary drug plan and enroll in itYes; Extra Help lowers Part D premiums, deductibles and copays

SeniorCare income levels

DHS sets SeniorCare levels by income as a share of the federal poverty level (FPL), counting your income and your spouse's if you live together. DHS updates the dollar amounts each year on its SeniorCare FPL page.

LevelIncomeHow it works
Level 1Up to 160% of FPLNo deductible or spenddown; a copay for each covered drug
Level 2AAbove 160% up to 200%A yearly deductible (you pay the SeniorCare rate until it's met), then copays
Level 2BAbove 200% up to 240%A larger yearly deductible, then copays; rebate-agreement drugs only
Level 3Above 240%A spenddown (your income above 240% of FPL, paid at retail price), then the Level 2B deductible, then copays

Who might choose which

These are general patterns, not advice for your situation. Compare your own drugs and costs.

  • Keeping SeniorCare only may suit someone at Level 1 or 2A whose drugs SeniorCare covers, who fills prescriptions in Wisconsin, and who doesn't qualify for Extra Help. Because SeniorCare is creditable, you can join Part D later without a penalty as long as SeniorCare doesn't lapse.
  • Adding Part D may suit someone who qualifies for Extra Help: DHS notes that lower-income people may get better coverage from Part D with Extra Help if their drugs are covered. It may also suit someone at Level 3 with a large spenddown, since Part D's yearly cap limits costs; someone who spends months out of state; or someone who wants a Medicare Advantage plan that includes drug coverage.
  • Having both may suit someone whose Part D plan leaves costs SeniorCare can help with. Your pharmacy bills Part D first and SeniorCare last; the federal waiver describes SeniorCare as filling a gap for members with Part D.

Don't let SeniorCare lapse without other coverage. If SeniorCare ends and you go 63 days or more without creditable drug coverage, your Part D premium can go up at least 1% for each month without coverage, for as long as you have Part D. If you're switching to Part D, DHS advises staying on SeniorCare until your Part D coverage begins.

How to compare

  1. List your drugs and doses. Check whether SeniorCare covers them at your level and whether each Part D plan's formulary does.
  2. Estimate a year of costs: SeniorCare's enrollment fee plus your deductible or spenddown and copays, against a Part D plan's premiums and cost sharing up to the $2,400 cap.
  3. Check Extra Help. Apply through Social Security at 1-800-772-1213; applying also starts a Medicare Savings Program application with Wisconsin. See Extra Help in Wisconsin.
  4. Mind the dates. SeniorCare starts the month after you apply. Part D changes are usually made October 15 to December 7.
  5. Get help if you want it. SeniorCare Customer Service is at 800-657-2038 (TTY 711). To compare Part D plans from the companies they work with, you can request a call from a licensed insurance agent.

Related: Should I choose SeniorCare or Part D?, Is SeniorCare creditable coverage?, Do I need Part D if I have SeniorCare? and SeniorCare income limits.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is SeniorCare creditable coverage for Medicare Part D?

Yes. Wisconsin DHS says SeniorCare is creditable coverage, as good as the standard Medicare Part D plan, so you won't have a late enrollment penalty if you choose SeniorCare instead of Part D. If SeniorCare ends and you go 63 days or more without creditable coverage, a penalty can apply when you later join Part D.

Can I have SeniorCare and Medicare Part D at the same time?

Yes. DHS says you can enroll in both programs at the same time or just one. Your pharmacy bills Part D first and SeniorCare after it, because SeniorCare is the payer of last resort.

Who can't get SeniorCare?

People under 65, people who aren't Wisconsin residents, and people enrolled in a full-benefit Medicaid program such as BadgerCare Plus. Having a Medicare Savings Program doesn't keep you out of SeniorCare.

How do I apply for SeniorCare?

Mail the SeniorCare application (form F-10076) with the yearly enrollment fee, or call SeniorCare Customer Service at 800-657-2038 (TTY 711) to ask for one. You can apply starting the month you turn 65, coverage begins the month after you apply, and you renew every year.

Licensed insurance agents who can help Wisconsin residents by phone

These independent insurance agents are licensed in Wisconsin and work with Benefits Life, the publisher of this site. When they enroll you in a plan, the agent and Benefits Life may be paid by the insurance company. Learn more.

Wendi Schoonover

Wendi Schoonover

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Tulsa, OK

Robin Depies

Robin Depies

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Colorado Springs, CO · English

Berenice Suarez

Berenice Suarez

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Colorado Springs, CO · English, Spanish

Andrea Ensch

Andrea Ensch

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Colorado Springs, CO · English

See all agents licensed in Wisconsin →

Request a call from

Only this agent gets your request. No cost to you.