Why scammers target Medicare in Wisconsin
Wisconsin has 1,376,185 people with Medicare (CMS, July 2026), and this fall about 58,451 of them must choose new coverage for 2027 because their plan or company is leaving (see plans ending in 2027). Change brings calls, and scammers use the confusion. The pattern to watch for is care you didn't need, didn't get or didn't agree to, billed under your name, and callers who want your Medicare number.
Warning signs
- A call, text or visit from "Medicare." The FTC says Medicare won't call or visit you to sell you anything, and Medicare representatives ask for information only if you contacted them first.
- A "new card" pitch. Cards are mailed at no cost. Anyone who says you must pay for a new card, or confirm your number to get one, is running a scam.
- Tests, braces or supplies "at no cost to you" if you share your Medicare number. HHS-OIG warns about cheek-swab genetic tests and orthotic braces offered by phone, TV ads, booths and door-to-door visits.
- Pressure and urgency: threats that you'll lose benefits, demands for gift cards or cryptocurrency, or a caller who won't let you hang up. Caller ID can be faked.
- Statement surprises: services, equipment or visits on your Medicare Summary Notice or plan Explanation of Benefits that you don't recognize.
- A plan you didn't choose. A new plan card or welcome letter you didn't expect can mean someone enrolled you without your permission.
Treat your Medicare number like a credit card number. Give it only to your doctors and other providers, your insurance companies and people you trust to help with your Medicare. If anyone else asks for it, hang up.
Common scams
Card and "benefits ending" calls
Callers say your Medicare card is being replaced, your benefits are ending, or your record needs "updating," and ask you to confirm your Medicare or bank number. Hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE yourself. More: someone called saying they'll send me a new Medicare card. Is it a scam? and how to report Medicare scam calls in Wisconsin.
Genetic tests and braces
HHS-OIG says that if Medicare denies the claim for a test you didn't need, you could owe the full cost. If a test kit, brace or other equipment arrives that your doctor didn't order, don't accept it: refuse it or return it, and write down the sender's name and the date.
Plan sales calls during Open Enrollment
Open Enrollment runs through December 7, 2026. Medicare's marketing rules bar plans and agents from cold calls, unsolicited texts and door-to-door sales (42 CFR 422.2264). Wisconsin also has its own Do Not Call law, run by the Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection (DATCP). If someone signed you up for a plan you didn't choose, call 1-800-MEDICARE.
Medicare supplement sales
Wisconsin's Medicare supplement policies have their own structure (a Basic policy plus optional riders), and Wisconsin doesn't sell the lettered plans (such as Plan G) used in most states, so ask questions if someone pitches one. Before you buy, check the agent's license with OCI's license lookup. Wisconsin gives you 30 days to review a new Medicare supplement policy and return it for a refund (Wis. Stat. 632.73(2m)). See Medigap in Wisconsin.
Where to report fraud in Wisconsin
| What happened | Who to contact |
|---|---|
| Medicare billing you don't recognize, or a suspicious "Medicare" call | 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), TTY 1-877-486-2048 |
| Any Medicare fraud, waste or abuse | HHS Office of Inspector General: 1-800-HHS-TIPS (1-800-447-8477), TTY 1-800-377-4950, or oig.hhs.gov |
| Help deciding whether it's fraud, and reporting it | Senior Medicare Patrol, national line: 1-877-808-2468 (smpresource.org) |
| Insurance fraud by an agent, an insurer or anyone else, including Medicare supplement policies | Office of the Commissioner of Insurance: online fraud portal or [email protected] |
| A complaint about how an agent or insurer treated you | OCI complaints: 1-800-236-8517 or 608-266-3585 (TTY 711), or oci.wi.gov |
| Fraud in Wisconsin Medicaid, SeniorCare or other DHS programs, such as billing for services not provided | DHS Office of the Inspector General fraud hotline: 1-877-865-3432, or its online form |
| Impersonation scams, unwanted sales calls and other consumer fraud | DATCP Consumer Protection Hotline: (800) 422-7128; also the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov |
| Someone used your identity to get care | Tell your provider or plan, and report it at IdentityTheft.gov |
Have your Medicare number, the provider's or caller's name and number, the date and your statement in front of you when you call.
About the Senior Medicare Patrol
The Senior Medicare Patrol (SMP) helps people with Medicare, families and caregivers prevent, detect and report health care fraud, errors and abuse. Its national resource center is supported by the federal Administration for Community Living. Call the national line, 1-877-808-2468, about suspected fraud.
How to protect yourself
- Read every statement. Set up a Medicare.gov account to see Original Medicare claims soon after they're processed, and read your plan's Explanation of Benefits.
- Keep a calendar of doctor visits, tests and deliveries, and compare it with your statements.
- Hang up on cold calls in English, Spanish, Hmong or any language. Call back only at a number you look up yourself.
- Refuse deliveries you didn't order, and report them.
- Check any agent's license with OCI before you share information.
- Help a parent review statements each month. See caregivers and Medicare and helping a parent with Medicare.
If you were affected
Report it first. If a denial or billing problem followed, see Medicare appeals in Wisconsin; every official number is on Wisconsin Medicare contacts. Once the problem is reported, a licensed insurance agent who works with Benefits Life can explain plans from the companies they work with and when you can change; you can request a call from a licensed insurance agent or find an independent licensed insurance agent.
Sources
- HHS Office of Inspector General — Report fraud
- HHS-OIG — Fraud alert: genetic testing scam
- HHS-OIG — Fraud alert: nationwide brace scam
- Federal Trade Commission — Medicare fraud affects everyone (May 2026)
- Federal Trade Commission — Hang up on Medicare card scams
- SMP National Resource Center
- Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance — Insurance Fraud
- Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance — Types of Complaints
- Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance — License look-up
- Wisconsin Statutes ch. 632 — Insurance contracts (632.73(2m), right to return a Medicare supplement policy)
- Wisconsin Department of Health Services — Report public assistance fraud
- Wisconsin DATCP — Consumer Protection
- eCFR — 42 CFR 422.2264, Beneficiary contact
- CMS — Medicare Monthly Enrollment (Wisconsin)
Frequently asked questions
Is someone calling about a new Medicare card a scam?
Almost always. Medicare cards are mailed at no cost, and the FTC says anyone who asks you to pay for one is running a scam. Hang up, don't confirm your Medicare number, and call 1-800-MEDICARE yourself if you're unsure.
Who handles insurance fraud by an agent in Wisconsin?
The Office of the Commissioner of Insurance (OCI). Use its online insurance fraud portal or email [email protected]; OCI can act administratively and refer criminal conduct to district attorneys or the Wisconsin Department of Justice. Report Medicare plan sales problems to 1-800-MEDICARE too.
Where do I report Wisconsin Medicaid or SeniorCare fraud?
To the Wisconsin Department of Health Services' Office of the Inspector General, through its fraud hotline, 1-877-865-3432, or its online form. It investigates tips such as billing Medicaid for services or equipment that weren't provided.
Can a licensed insurance agent help if a scam left me in the wrong plan?
After you report it to 1-800-MEDICARE, a licensed insurance agent can explain your options and when you can change plans. You can request a call from a licensed insurance agent.
Medicare in your Wisconsin county
Plans, licensed agents and help, county by county: Milwaukee · Dane · Waukesha · Brown · Racine · Outagamie · Winnebago · Kenosha · Rock · Marathon · Washington · La Crosse · Sheboygan · Eau Claire · Walworth · Fond du Lac · St. Croix · Ozaukee · Dodge · Jefferson · All 72 counties →