2027 alertSecurity Health Plan, UnitedHealthcare, Aspirus Health Plan and 2 other companies end some Medicare Advantage plans in Wisconsin on December 31. (CMS data) 15 days left in Annual Enrollment (ends Dec. 7).Is your plan ending? →
Questions

Someone called saying they will send me a new Medicare card. Is it a scam?

Almost always, yes. The Federal Trade Commission says Medicare cards are mailed at no cost, that anyone who asks you to pay for one is a scammer, and that Medicare won't call to sell you anything. If someone calls you in Wisconsin to confirm your Medicare number for a new card, hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE yourself.

What to do during the call

  1. Don't confirm anything. Not your Medicare number, Social Security number or bank details, even if the caller already knows some of them.
  2. Hang up. Caller ID can be faked to say "Medicare" or show a government number. Don't call back the number the caller gives you.
  3. Call Medicare yourself at 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227, TTY 1-877-486-2048) if you're worried about your card. Help is available in Spanish.
  4. Report it to 1-800-MEDICARE or HHS-OIG at 1-800-HHS-TIPS (1-800-447-8477). In Wisconsin, also to the DATCP Consumer Protection Hotline, 800-422-7128, or at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

What the card scam sounds like

What the caller saysThe truth
"You need a new plastic or chip card."Cards are mailed at no cost. The FTC says anyone asking for money for one is a scammer.
"Confirm your Medicare number so we can send it."The FTC says Medicare won't ask for personal information to send you a card, and its representatives ask for information only if you called first.
"Your benefits will be cancelled."Pressure and urgency are classic scam signs. Hang up and check with 1-800-MEDICARE.
"Your plan is ending and you must switch today."If your plan ends, you get a letter. You have until December 7, and a special period through February 28, 2027.
"You qualify for a test or brace at no cost."HHS-OIG says these offers are often a way to get your Medicare number and bill in your name.

If you already gave your number

Call 1-800-MEDICARE and explain what happened. Then check your Medicare Summary Notice or plan statements every month for care, tests or equipment you didn't get. If equipment arrives that your doctor didn't order, refuse or return it and note who sent it. Report identity theft at IdentityTheft.gov.

Why it matters now in Wisconsin

CMS data show about 58,451 Wisconsinites with Medicare must choose new coverage for 2027 because their plan is ending or leaving their county. That confusion helps scammers. Milwaukee, Racine and Kenosha counties have the state's highest Hispanic shares (Census, 2024); if a caller pressures you in Spanish, the same rules apply. To check whether your plan really is ending, see plans ending in 2027.

Related: how to report Medicare scam calls in Wisconsin, how to appeal a denial and hospital discharge appeals. More in Medicare fraud in Wisconsin.

Sources

More questions in this guide

Part of the guide: Medicare appeals in Wisconsin · All questions

Frequently asked questions

I gave my Medicare number to the caller. What should I do?

Call 1-800-MEDICARE, explain what happened and check your statements for services you didn't get. The national Senior Medicare Patrol, 1-877-808-2468, can help you check whether someone is using your number.

How do I get a real replacement Medicare card?

Log in to your Medicare.gov account to print an official copy, or call 1-800-MEDICARE yourself to have one mailed. You never have to pay for a card.

Can a plan call me because mine is ending in 2027?

Your plan sends letters, and an agent may call only if you asked. Federal rules (42 CFR 422.2264) bar unsolicited sales calls. Use the numbers on your card or letter.

Licensed insurance agents who can help Wisconsin residents by phone

These independent insurance agents are licensed in Wisconsin and work with Benefits Life, the publisher of this site. When they enroll you in a plan, the agent and Benefits Life may be paid by the insurance company. Learn more.

Berenice Suarez

Berenice Suarez

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Colorado Springs, CO · English, Spanish

David Gresl

David Gresl

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Las Vegas, NV · English

Wendi Schoonover

Wendi Schoonover

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Tulsa, OK

Robin Depies

Robin Depies

Accepting new clients

Independent insurance agent licensed in Wisconsin

Colorado Springs, CO · English

See all agents licensed in Wisconsin →

Request a call from

Only this agent gets your request. No cost to you.