How does each option work?
Original Medicare with Wisconsin Medigap: Medicare pays first, and your Medigap policy pays some or all of what's left. In Wisconsin, every policy starts with a Basic core of 17 benefits (Ins 3.39 (5t)(d)), and you add riders such as the Part A deductible, Part B excess charges, extra home health visits or foreign travel. You add a standalone Part D plan for drugs; CMS lists 8 in Wisconsin for 2027. See Medigap in Wisconsin.
Medicare Advantage: a private plan approved by Medicare covers your Part A and Part B care. Most plans include Part D, use a provider network, and charge copays or coinsurance as you use care, up to a yearly limit. See Medicare Advantage in Wisconsin.
You need Part A and Part B either way, and you keep paying your Part B premium either way. In July 2026, 789,533 of Wisconsin's 1,376,185 people with Medicare were in Medicare Advantage or another Medicare health plan, and 586,652 in Original Medicare, per CMS.
Wisconsin Basic policy and riders vs. Medicare Advantage
| Question | Original Medicare + Wisconsin Medigap + Part D | Medicare Advantage |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly premiums | Part B, plus the Basic policy, plus each rider you add, plus Part D. | Part B, plus the plan's premium if it has one. |
| Bills when you get care | Depends on your riders. With the Part A deductible and Part B excess riders, you mainly pay the Part B deductible. | Copays or coinsurance for most services, set by the plan. |
| Yearly limit on medical costs | None in Original Medicare alone. The 50% and 25% cost-sharing policies have yearly limits, which have matched the federal Plan K and L limits ($8,360 and $4,180 for 2027). With a Basic policy and riders, little may be left to pay. | Required: up to $9,850 in network in 2027 (a PPO's combined limit can be up to $14,800). |
| Wisconsin mandated benefits | Included in the Basic policy: 30 extra skilled nursing days, at least 40 home care visits, chiropractic care, 365 extra hospital days and more. | Not required; OCI doesn't regulate Medicare Advantage plans. |
| Doctors and hospitals | Any provider in the U.S. that accepts Medicare (Medicare Select policies use a network for the supplement benefits). | The plan's network. HMOs generally cover out-of-network care only for emergencies and urgent care; PPOs cover it at a higher cost. |
| Renewal | Guaranteed renewable for life; can't be canceled for your health. | Renewed year by year; a plan can end or leave your county. |
| Drugs | Through a Part D plan (or other creditable coverage such as SeniorCare), Part D capped at $2,400 in 2027. | Usually included, with the same $2,400 cap. |
| Travel | Works in every state. The foreign travel rider pays at least 80% of emergency care in the first 60 days of a trip abroad. | Tied to your service area; more than 6 months away ends enrollment unless the plan has a visitor or traveler program (42 CFR 422.74). |
| Referrals and prior approval | No referrals. Medicare's rules decide what's covered. | Many plans need referrals or prior authorization for some services. |
Medicare Advantage plans may offer extra benefits such as dental, vision or hearing. Extra benefits vary by plan and county, may have limits and costs, and not every plan offers them. Check a plan's Summary of Benefits or Evidence of Coverage.
Wisconsin also has a third option in 26 counties: Medicare Cost plans (14 for 2027), which use a network but let Original Medicare pay its share when you go outside it. See Medicare Cost plans in Wisconsin.
Switching later: what Wisconsin's rules allow
| Change | Health questions? | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Buy Medigap in the 6 months after your Part B starts, at any age | No | Ins 3.39 (3r)(a) |
| Buy Medigap in the 6 months after you turn 65, if you got Part B earlier because of a disability | No | Ins 3.39 (3r)(a), second window |
| Switch from one Medigap policy to another, or add a rider | Yes, usually | No birthday or anniversary rule in Wisconsin |
| Leave Medicare Advantage within 12 months of joining it for the first time | No | Trial right, Ins 3.39 (34)(b) |
| Your Medicare Advantage or Cost plan ends, leaves your county, or you move away | No | Guaranteed issue; apply within 63 days after coverage ends |
| You dropped employer coverage for Medicare Advantage and leave within 12 months | No | Wisconsin-only right, Ins 3.39 (34)(b) 1r. |
| Leave Medicare Advantage for Medigap at any other time | Usually yes | Only a guaranteed issue right avoids health questions |
| Switch Medicare Advantage plans | No | October 15 to December 7, and January 1 to March 31 |
In short: it's easier to start with Medigap and move to Medicare Advantage than the other way around. Any new Medigap policy can be returned within 30 days for a premium refund (Wis. Stat. 632.73 (2m)).
Life-event guide
| If you are... | What to know in Wisconsin |
|---|---|
| Turning 65 and starting Part B | Your 6-month Medigap open enrollment starts with Part B. It's the one time any company must sell you any policy and rider combination without health questions. See turning 65 in Wisconsin. |
| Working past 65 with employer coverage | If you delay Part B, your Medigap window waits too. See working past 65. |
| Retiring from a Wisconsin public employer | ETF requires Part A and B and offers group Medicare options that include Part D. Check with ETF before buying anything else. See ETF vs. individual plans. |
| Losing employer coverage that paid before Medicare | Wisconsin gives a guaranteed issue right to buy Medigap within 63 days. |
| In a plan ending for 2027 | About 58,451 people must choose new coverage. Choose by December 31, 2026; you have until February 28, 2027, and Medigap guaranteed issue until 63 days after the plan ends. See plans ending in 2027. |
| Wintering in Arizona, Florida or Texas | Original Medicare and Medigap work anywhere in the U.S. A Medicare Advantage plan may cover only emergencies and urgent care there. See snowbirds. |
| Using doctors in Minnesota, Illinois, Iowa or Michigan | Original Medicare pays any provider that accepts Medicare. For Medicare Advantage, check that out-of-state providers are in the network. See rural Wisconsin. |
| Getting Wisconsin Medicaid | With full Medicaid you usually don't need Medigap; you can suspend a policy for up to 24 months if you ask within 90 days. Losing Medicaid later gives a guaranteed issue right. See D-SNP vs. Original Medicare and Medicaid. |
| Under 65 with Medicare because of a disability | Your Medigap open enrollment starts with Part B, and you get a second one at 65. See Medigap under 65. |
How to decide
- List your doctors, hospitals and drugs, including specialists and any providers in another state.
- Check what's sold in your county on our counties page, and check each plan's network for your providers.
- Compare a typical year and a bad year: premiums plus expected copays against the plan's out-of-pocket limit, or the Basic policy plus the riders you'd add.
- Think about time away and how each option handles care there.
- Mind your timing. Your Medigap open enrollment or a guaranteed issue period is when a company must sell you a policy without health questions.
To compare Medigap policies and Medicare Advantage plans from the companies they work with, you can request a call from a licensed insurance agent, or see plans for your ZIP code. See also Medicare Advantage or Original Medicare in Wisconsin? and Why are Wisconsin Medigap plans different?
Sources
- Wisconsin Administrative Code — Ins 3.39 (Basic policy, riders, open enrollment, guaranteed issue)
- Wisconsin Statutes — s. 632.73 (2m), 30-day return of Medicare supplement policies
- OCI — 2026 Guide to Health Insurance for People with Medicare in Wisconsin, PI-002
- Medicare.gov — Compare Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage
- Medicare.gov — Learn how Medigap works
- eCFR — 42 CFR 422.74 (absence from the service area; visitor and traveler programs)
- CMS — Medicare Advantage and Part D Landscape files, contract year 2027 (plan counts)
- CMS — Medicare Monthly Enrollment (Wisconsin)
- Wisconsin Department of Employee Trust Funds — Medicare and ETF
Frequently asked questions
Is Medigap or Medicare Advantage better in Wisconsin?
Neither is better for everyone. Medigap with Original Medicare suits people who want any provider in the U.S. that accepts Medicare, travel or winter out of state, or use hospitals across a state line. Medicare Advantage suits people comfortable with a local network who want drug coverage in one plan.
Can I have Medicare Advantage and Medigap at the same time?
No. A Medigap policy doesn't pay anything while you're in Medicare Advantage, and a company can't sell you one then unless it starts after your plan ends.
If I choose Medicare Advantage, can I switch to Medigap later in Wisconsin?
You can return to Original Medicare during Open Enrollment or the January to March window, but a Medigap company can ask health questions unless you have a guaranteed issue right, such as the 12-month trial right or your plan ending. Wisconsin has no birthday rule.
What is closest to Medigap Plan G in Wisconsin?
A Basic policy with the Part A deductible rider and the Part B excess charges rider pays most of what Plan G pays elsewhere; add the foreign travel rider if you travel abroad. Each rider has its own premium, so compare the total.
Medicare in your Wisconsin county
Plans, licensed agents and help, county by county: Milwaukee · Dane · Waukesha · Brown · Racine · Outagamie · Winnebago · Kenosha · Rock · Marathon · Washington · La Crosse · Sheboygan · Eau Claire · Walworth · Fond du Lac · St. Croix · Ozaukee · Dodge · Jefferson · All 72 counties →