2027 alertSecurity Health Plan, UnitedHealthcare, Aspirus Health Plan and 2 other companies end some Medicare Advantage plans in Wisconsin on December 31. (CMS data) 15 days left in Annual Enrollment (ends Dec. 7).Is your plan ending? →
For licensed agents

Wisconsin Medigap for agents: the policy design and your duties under Ins 3.39

Wisconsin doesn't use lettered Medigap Plans A–N. Every policy has a Basic core with state-mandated benefits, optional riders are priced and sold separately, and there is no birthday rule. Agents must give OCI's guide (PI-002) when inviting an application, deliver the outline of coverage, use the replacement notice, check suitability and forward applications within 7 days (Wis. Adm. Code Ins 3.39).

The Wisconsin design: Basic policy plus riders

Wisconsin uses its own standardized design instead of the federal Plans A–N. Every individual Medicare supplement policy has a Basic core, and each optional benefit is a rider that is priced and sold separately. Benefits depend on when the client was first eligible for Medicare: before June 1, 2010; June 1, 2010 through December 31, 2019; or on or after January 1, 2020 ("newly eligible", Ins 3.39(3g)). This page describes the newly eligible rules.

What the Basic policy covers

Ins 3.39(5t)(d) lists 17 Basic benefits. Beyond the federal core (Part A hospital coinsurance and lifetime reserve days, Part B coinsurance after the deductible, the first 3 pints of blood, hospice coinsurance, skilled nursing coinsurance for days 21–100), Wisconsin requires:

  • 365 more lifetime hospital days at 100% after Medicare's hospital days run out, with no balance billing;
  • at least 175 lifetime days of inpatient psychiatric care beyond Medicare's limit;
  • 30 days of skilled nursing care Medicare doesn't cover, and kidney disease treatment;
  • at least 40 home care visits a year;
  • chiropractic care, diabetes treatment and supplies (not outpatient prescription drugs), hospital or surgery-center charges and anesthesia for dental care, breast reconstruction, and preventive care Medicare doesn't cover, up to a minimum set in the rule.

Optional riders (newly eligible)

Ins 3.39(5t)(e) allows these riders, each "available for purchase separately at any time, subject to underwriting":

  • Part A deductible (100%), or a 50% Part A deductible rider (a client can't hold both);
  • Additional home health care (365 visits a year);
  • Part B copayment or coinsurance;
  • Part B excess charges;
  • Foreign travel emergency.

The Part B deductible rider can't be sold to anyone first eligible on or after January 1, 2020. Clients first eligible earlier may buy it if an insurer offers it, but can't hold it together with the Part B copayment rider.

Select, cost-sharing and high-deductible plans

  • Medicare Select (Ins 3.39(30t)) pays full supplemental benefits only through the insurer's network, except for emergencies and services the network can't provide. After a Select policy has been in force 6 months, the insurer must let the client move to a comparable or lesser non-network policy without health questions.
  • 50% and 25% cost-sharing plans (Ins 3.39(5t)(g)–(h)) pay a share of most cost sharing until the client reaches an annual out-of-pocket limit, then 100% for the rest of the calendar year. The limits are indexed each year.
  • The high-deductible plan (Ins 3.39(5t)(k)) pays after the federal high-deductible amount ($3,050 for 2027). For the newly eligible, the Part B deductible counts toward that deductible but isn't reimbursed.

Medigap policies sold since 2006 don't cover prescription drugs, so clients with Original Medicare need a separate Part D plan or other creditable coverage.

Open enrollment, guaranteed issue and the free look

  • Open enrollment (Ins 3.39(3r)): six months starting with the first month of Part B, at any age. People who enrolled in Part B under 65 get a second six-month window starting the month they turn 65. Insurers can't deny, condition or price differently based on health, and can't charge tobacco rates in this window.
  • Guaranteed issue (Ins 3.39(34)): the federal triggers (a Medicare Advantage or Cost plan ends or the client moves away, trial rights within 12 months, insurer insolvency or misconduct) plus Wisconsin's own: an employer plan's cost to the client rises more than 25% and above the Medigap premium; an employer plan primary to Medicare ends; the client left employer coverage for Medicare Advantage and disenrolled within 12 months; a Select network hospital leaves with no other within 30 minutes or 30 miles; or the client loses Medicaid. The window generally ends 63 days after coverage ends. People whose 2027 plan is ending have this right.
  • No birthday or anniversary rule. 2023 AB 404 and SB 412 would have created a 30-day birthday window; both failed to pass on April 15, 2024. Outside open enrollment and guaranteed issue, applications are underwritten.
  • Free look: 30 days, with the refund going directly to the payer (Wis. Stat. 632.73(2m); Ins 3.39(22)(e)).
  • Preexisting conditions: a waiting period of at most 6 months (Wis. Stat. 632.76(2)(b)), reduced or waived in open enrollment based on prior creditable coverage, and none with guaranteed issue.

Your duties as an agent under Ins 3.39

  1. Give OCI's guide at first contact. When you invite someone to apply, give them the current "Guide to Health Insurance for People with Medicare in Wisconsin" (OCI PI-002) in at least 12-point type, and the insurer must get written acknowledgement (Ins 3.39(11)).
  2. Deliver the outline of coverage. Give the Wisconsin-format outline at application and get a signed acknowledgement. If the policy issued differs from what was applied for, a substitute outline with the required notice goes with the policy (Ins 3.39(4t)(b)).
  3. Complete the application statements. The application carries the questions in Ins 3.39(23)(a), signed by the applicant and you. On a signed supplementary form, list the health policies you sold the applicant that are still in force, and any you sold in the past 5 years that are no longer in force (Ins 3.39(23)(b)).
  4. Use the replacement notice. If the sale replaces coverage, give the Appendix 7 notice before the policy is issued. You and the applicant both sign it; the applicant keeps a copy and the insurer keeps one (Ins 3.39(23)(c)–(d)).
  5. Check suitability. Make reasonable efforts to determine whether the purchase or replacement is appropriate. Never sell someone a second Medicare supplement policy (Ins 3.39(25)(a)–(b)).
  6. Meet the deadlines. Forward applications to the insurer within 7 calendar days and premium within 7 days, and don't take an application more than 3 months before the person is eligible (Ins 3.39(25)(c)–(d)).

Marketing and compensation rules

  • No twisting, no high-pressure tactics, and no cold lead advertising, meaning any marketing that hides that its purpose is solicitation and that an agent will contact the person (Ins 3.39(24)). Never discourage anyone from filing a complaint with OCI.
  • "Medicare Supplement" and "Medigap" may be used only for policies that meet the rule.
  • Commission structure (Ins 3.39(21)): first-year compensation is capped relative to renewal compensation, renewals must be level for a minimum number of years, replacement sales are paid no more than the renewal level, bonuses, gifts, prizes and awards count as compensation, and sales to people under 66 or under guaranteed issue must be paid on the same basis as other sales. Ask each insurer for its schedule.
  • Refunds and returned premium go directly to the insured, not through you (Ins 3.39(14t)(b)).

Medicare Advantage, Part D and Cost plan sales follow CMS's marketing rules instead; see Selling Medicare under CMS rules. Licensing is covered in How to get a Wisconsin insurance license.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Does Wisconsin have a Medigap birthday rule?

No. Wisconsin has no birthday, anniversary or annual switch right. Bills to create a birthday window (2023 AB 404 and SB 412) failed to pass on April 15, 2024. Outside open enrollment and guaranteed issue, a switch is medically underwritten.

Can someone newly eligible buy the Part B deductible rider?

No. Under Ins 3.39(5t), people first eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020 can't buy the Part B deductible rider. People first eligible before 2020 may buy it if an insurer offers it.

What do I have to hand a prospect before they apply?

The current OCI guide (PI-002) when you invite them to apply, with written acknowledgement, and the outline of coverage at application, also acknowledged in writing. If the sale replaces coverage, the Appendix 7 replacement notice before the policy is issued.

Do Wisconsin's Medigap rules cover under-65 beneficiaries?

Yes. Open enrollment runs six months from the first month of Part B at any age, and people who enrolled under 65 get a second six-month window at 65 (Ins 3.39(3r)). Insurers may not underwrite under-65 applicants more strictly during open enrollment.