The trade-offs for a two-home life
| Original Medicare + Wisconsin Medigap | Medicare Advantage | |
|---|---|---|
| Routine care in your winter state | Any provider in the U.S. that accepts Medicare | Depends on the network; some PPOs pay out of network at a higher cost |
| Emergencies away from home | Covered | Covered anywhere in the U.S. |
| Months away allowed | No limit in the U.S. | More than 6 in a row ends your enrollment, unless the plan has a visitor or traveler program (up to 12) |
| Drug coverage | Separate Part D plan (Medigap policies sold since 2006 don't cover drugs) | Usually included |
| Changing later | Insurer may ask health questions outside open enrollment and guaranteed issue | You can switch plans each fall |
Medicare Advantage plans have their own costs and rules, and Medigap policies have their own premiums. Prices vary, so compare the specific options for your county.
What's different about Medigap in Wisconsin
Wisconsin doesn't sell the lettered Plans A to N. Every policy has a Basic core with Wisconsin's required benefits, and you add optional riders, such as the Part A deductible, Part B excess charges or foreign travel emergency. That lets a snowbird pick a policy for travel. See Medigap in Wisconsin.
The timing is what matters most:
- Open enrollment: for 6 months starting the month your Part B begins, an insurer can't turn you down or charge more because of your health (Ins 3.39 (3r)).
- No birthday rule: after that window, switching or buying a Medigap policy usually means answering health questions, unless a guaranteed-issue right applies.
- Guaranteed issue: you get 63 days to buy a policy without health questions if, for example, your Medicare Advantage plan ends, leaves your area, or you move out of its area, or if you're within 12 months of trying Medicare Advantage for the first time.
How to decide
- Count your months away. More than 6 in a row rules out most Medicare Advantage plans unless the plan's visitor or traveler program covers where you go.
- List the care you'd need in each state. Ongoing specialist care in your winter state points toward Original Medicare and Medigap, or a plan whose network covers it.
- Check prescriptions in both places. Ask about network pharmacies and mail order.
- Think about the next ten years. Choosing Medigap during open enrollment protects you even if your health changes; switching from Medicare Advantage to Medigap later may not be possible.
- Review every fall. Some Wisconsin plans end in 2027; see plans ending in 2027.
Related: does Medicare work in Arizona, Florida or Texas, how long you can be away from a Medicare Advantage area and prescriptions out of state. The side-by-side is in Wisconsin Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage, and the full guide is Snowbirds and wintering out of state. To compare options from the companies they work with, you can request a call from a licensed insurance agent.
Sources
- Wisconsin Administrative Code — Ins 3.39, Medicare supplement policies
- Wisconsin OCI — Guide to Health Insurance for People with Medicare in Wisconsin, PI-002 (R 04/2026)
- eCFR — 42 CFR 422.74, Disenrollment by the MA organization
- eCFR — 42 CFR 422.113, Emergency and urgently needed services
- Medicare.gov — How Original Medicare works
More questions in this guide
- Can I use my Medicare in Puerto Rico?
- Should I change my residence to Florida or Arizona for Medicare?
- Does Medicare cover me if I travel to Mexico?
- Does my Medicare work in Arizona, Florida or Texas when I winter there?
- Can I fill prescriptions in Florida or Arizona with my Wisconsin Part D plan?
- How long can I be away from my Medicare Advantage plan's service area?
Part of the guide: Wisconsin snowbirds: Medicare when you winter out of state · All questions
Frequently asked questions
Does Wisconsin have a birthday rule that lets me switch Medigap policies later?
No. Wisconsin has no birthday or anniversary rule; bills to add one failed in April 2024. Outside open enrollment and guaranteed-issue situations, a Medigap insurer can ask health questions.
Can I try Medicare Advantage and go back to Medigap?
If you dropped a Medigap policy to join a Medicare Advantage plan for the first time and leave within 12 months, Wisconsin's rule (Ins 3.39 (34)) gives you a guaranteed right to buy a Medigap policy again.
Does a Wisconsin Medigap policy cover me abroad?
Only if your policy includes foreign travel emergency coverage, which in Wisconsin is usually an optional rider you buy separately.
Medicare in your Wisconsin county
Plans, licensed agents and help, county by county: Milwaukee · Dane · Waukesha · Brown · Racine · Outagamie · Winnebago · Kenosha · Rock · Marathon · Washington · La Crosse · Sheboygan · Eau Claire · Walworth · Fond du Lac · St. Croix · Ozaukee · Dodge · Jefferson · All 72 counties →